JANUARY 20, 2000

IOWA SUPREME COURT


State v. Birth, 604 N.W.2d 664 (Iowa 2000) (1/20/00).  Impeachment -- deferred judgment pursuant to unexpired probation pursuant to suspended sentence can serve as "prior conviction" under Iowa R. Evid. 609(a). Witness can be questioned about prior conviction under rule 609(a) where that conviction was the subject of a deferred judgment for which the probationary period had not been completed. The witness fell between two established rules: (1) reference cannot be made to a deferred judgment for which probation has been successfully completed as there is no "conviction" therefrom and (2) a defendant's guilty plea alone, without judgment or sentence, does amount to a conviction. "Until probation was completed, and the deferred judgment expunged, evidence of Franklin's guilty plea was appropriate for impeachment under rule of evidence 609(a)."  

State v. Buchanan, 604 N.W.2d 667 (Iowa 2000) (1/20/00).  Felon status from aggravated misdemeanor. Defendant qualified as a felon in possession of a firearm by virtue of his previous conviction of an aggravated misdemeanor involving a weapon. While the statute provides that misdemeanors carrying incarceration terms of less than two years do not qualify as felonies for this purpose, an exception applies where the misdemeanor involved a firearm, as in defendant's case. 

State v. Conroy, 604 N.W.2d 636 (Iowa 2000) (1/20/00).  Reckless use of firearm: sufficiency of "recklessness" where use was admittedly intentional.  "Reckless", as used in the "reckless use of a firearm" statute, modifies the manner in which a firearm is intentionally discharged, not the user's mental state in so doing. "Thus, the statute requires that the discharge of a firearm occasion unreasonable risk to others; intent to injure is irrelevant."  Substantial evidence of recklessness existed in defendant's having shot out the windows of the victim's truck, parked at the end of to the victim's home overlooking a field, in the middle of the night, after drinking heavily.  

State v. Gilliland, 604 N.W.2d 666 (Iowa 2000) (1/20/00).  Deferred judgment not authorized for juvenile where original jurisdiction was in district court. Juvenile who is charged with crime over which adult court has original jurisdiction is not eligible for deferred judgment; relevant statute provides for deferred judgments where original jurisdiction is in juvenile court but defendant is waived to district court. 

State v. Miller, 606 N.W.2d 310 (Iowa 2000) (1/20/00).  Changed OWI law (expanding consideration of priors from 6 to 12 years). Present prosecution for an offense subject to enhancement based on prior offenses does not constitute a successive prosecution or punishment for the prior offenses. 

State v. Smith, 604 N.W.2d 662 (Iowa 2000) (1/20/00).  Sex abuse registry -- failure to "notify"  re change of address not encompassed in penalties pertaining to failure to register. Section 692A.7(1) only punishes a sexual offender's failure to register, not his or her failure to notify of a change of address. Thus, although offender is required to "notify" sheriff of a change in address, section 692A.7(1) does not provide a penalty for failure to do so.  [LEGISLATIVE ALERT: This problem is addressed in SF 2031].


Last updated:
October 05, 2004


CAVEAT:  The information on this web site does not constitute legal advice.  It is intended to provide general reference material and should not serve as a substitute for independent legal research and the exercise of sound prosecutorial judgment.  Unless specifically designated otherwise, nothing on this site constitutes an opinion of the Iowa Attorney General, the Iowa Department of Justice, or the Iowa County Attorneys Association.  Opinions on this site are slip opinions only and are subject to change before publication in the Northwest Reporter.

* -- Requires Adobe Acrobat Reader, obtainable at www.adobe.com